Outrageous Comedy, Strong Performances Highlight the Rep’s Self-Referential “Emma”

Emma
by Kate Hamill
Based on the Novel by Jane Austen
Directed by Tracy Brigden
The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
December 5, 2025

Jane Austen’s Emma is a classic that’s been adapted many times for various media, including more straightforward adaptations as well as updated re-imaginings such as the movie Clueless. The latest production at the Rep, adapted by Kate Hamill and directed by Tracy Brigden, isn’t a full-fledged reinvention, but it certainly has fun with the source material in terms of tone and style, and also in interpretation, with a decidedly 21st century take on the novel’s themes. It’s an inventive, energetically staged, slapstick-comic production that looks great and features some truly hilarious performances and moments.

Some streamlining is understandably necessary in adapting a book for the stage, and this show does a bit of that in terms of settings, events, and some characters who are given slightly different backstories than their novel counterparts. The basic story is the same, though, concentrating on wealthy young Emma Woodhouse (Adelin Phelps), who is pleased with herself after the wedding of her friend and former governess (Kathryn A. Bentley) to kindly neighbor Mr. Weston (Michael James Reed). Emma takes credit for setting the pair up, so she sets out to play matchmaker for her new protege, the young, socially awkward and less financially advantaged Harriet Smith (Lize Lewy) in hopes of finding her a “better” match than humble groundskeeper Robert Martin (Ryan Omar Stack), to the discouragement of her longtime friend Mr. Knightley (Louis Reyes McWilliams), who is doubtful of Emma’s motives and of her efforts’ potential benefits for Harriet. Of course, hijinks and hilarity ensue, as Emma’s efforts to match Harriet with the somewhat silly local vicar Mr. Elton (Jack Dryden) have unintended consequences, and more misunderstandings and presumptions lead to even more predicaments involving Mr. Weston’s long-absent son Frank Churchill (also Stack), the loquatious Miss Bates (Nancy Bell) and her much-lauded niece, Jane Fairfax (Maggie Newstead-Adams). It’s all quite fast-paced and over-the-top comic, which is hilarious and excellently timed, and the constant sparring/flirtation between Emma and Knightley is played up with delightful effect, and all the characters are given moments to shine as the story plays out in raucous, highly entertaining fashion.

The setup has been given a modern twist in that it’s all very meta, with Emma narrating the story and talking directly to the audience throughout the play, and at various moments reminding us that it’s a play based on a novel. Also, some themes that are implied in the novel and have been pointed out by scholars over the years have been given a much more direct interpretation here–saying the quiet parts out loud, so to speak. For instance, Emma’s mischief being attributed to the idleness of a pampered rich lady who isn’t allowed to do much else becomes a major theme of this version, and Mrs. Weston is given much more of a role as a voice of reason in this adaptation, as well as Harriet’s journey toward finding her own voice apart from Emma’s. It’s a feminist twist that’s not out of place because it is suggested in the novel, but the themes are stated much more openly here. It all works well, considering the energy and enthusiasm of the cast, the wittiness and intelligence of the script, and the clever staging and direction.

The cast is wonderful, led by Phelps’s somewhat wacky turn as the determined, increasingly frustrated Emma and by Lewy’s brilliant comic performance as the endearingly awkward and increasingly bold Harriet. The scenes between these two are among the highlights of the production, as are the scenes between Phelps and the also excellent McWilliams in a charming turn as Knightley. There are also memorable performances from Bentley as the wise Mrs. Weston, Bell as the friendly chatterbox Miss Bates, Newstead-Adams as the softspoken and mysterious Jane Fairfax, and Dryden in a hilarious turn as a somewhat unhinged Mr. Elton. There are also a number of impressive dual roles, led by Reed as the charming Mr. Weston and anxious Mr. Woodhouse, who extols the virtues of gruel at every opportunity. Stack is also excellent as the charming but evasive Frank Churchill and the earnest Robert Martin, and Olivia Balicki seems to be having a lot of fun as the besotted Mrs. Elton and the cranky, mostly mute Mrs. Bates. The ensemble energy is frantic and well-timed, adding much to the overall comic value and tone of the story.

Visually, this production is particularly striking, with a pop-up postcard style set by Margery Spack and Peter Spack that utilizes a turntable to change scenes and is surrounded by floral accents that suggest the countryside setting of the story. Jason Lynch’s lighting adds to the mood with style, as well, as does the memorable soundtrack by composer and sound designer John Gromade. There are also marvelously detailed period costumes by Dottie Marshall-Englis, and energetic choreography in the dance scenes by Sam Gaitsch. 

This is an Emma with energy, style, and substance. The characters are lively, the setting is vibrant, and the tone is upbeat and modern while also retaining the flair and style of Regency England. While it’s not exactly a holiday play, its energy and atmosphere make it a fitting show for the season at the Rep. 

The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis is presenting Emma until December 21, 2025