Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Music & Lyrics by Stephen Sondheim, Book by Hugh Wheeler
Directed by Colin Healy
Fly North Theatricals
July 18, 2026
I’ve seen Sweeney Todd done as a big show with a large cast and lavish production values, and also as a smaller show with a tighter budget, and it has worked in both of those situations because of a great cast and meticulous direction. Fly North Theatricals is going the “small” route with their latest production, and once again, it works, all because of thoughtful direction by Colin Healy and an excellent, well-chosen cast and crew that does justice to the script and Stephen Sondheim’s celebrated score. It’s also been made to fit ideally into the relatively small space at Fly North’s theatrical home, Greenfinch Theater & Dive.
Anyone familiar with this show will know it has a dark and creepy tone, and the subject matter is not for all ages. I won’t spoil too much, but I would say this is for older teens and up, age-wise. It follows the titular barber, Sweeney Todd (Chandler Spradling) as he returns to London after years of exile in Australia, seeking revenge on the sinister but outwardly pious Judge Turpin (Ken Haller), who is now raising Sweeney’s daughter, Johanna (Isobel Ramsey). The kind young sailor Anthony (Dereis Lambert), has helped Sweeney and soon meets Johanna and becomes instantly smitten. Meanwhile, Sweeney returns to his old place of residence and meets pie shop owner Mrs. Lovett (Jennelle Gilreath Owens), who is down on her luck making “The Worst Pies in London”. While Sweeney tries to restore his reputation as a barber and seeks to settle his score with the judge and his accomplice the Beadle (Matt Ingram), he and Mrs. Lovett soon discover a gruesome way of going into business together. Meanwhile, a mysterious Beggar Woman (Rachel Bailey) keeps turning up and unsettling those around her.
That’s about all I can recount without spoiling. It’s a dark and chilling tale, with some carefully placed humor to balance the mood, and an intricately constructed score with clever lyrics and a bit of a Victorian air in keeping with the setting. The demands on the cast are great, and this cast rises to the challenge well. Spradling and Owens are especially strong, with Spradling’s brooding energy and booming voice especially ideal, and Owens’s comic timing and vocals equally excellent. The chemistry between these two is commendable, and duets like “A Little Priest” bring down the house. Lambert and Ramsey are also strong as secondary couple Anthony and Johanna, both in stage presence and chemistry, and in marvelous vocals. Speaking of vocals, Ingram as the Beadle is especially strong in this area, standing out in the “Parlor Songs” sequence in Act 2 especially. There are also strong turns from Haller as the creepy Judge Turpin and Crispin Shininger as Tobias, a young man that Mrs. Lovett takes in. Bailey, as the Beggar woman, is also a standout, and there’s also a strong ensemble backing the leads and lending excellent vocals to the mix.
Technically, the Greenfinch space is a bit of a challenge, but I’ve seen it used very well before, and the set design here, by Colin Healy, Bradley Rohlf, and Lauren Perry, works well. The use of white curtains in some sequences is especially effective, as well as a rolling staircase piece. There’s also marvelous lighting by Healy and Perry that heightens the dark tone of the show. Jen Blum-Tatara’s costumes suit the characters well, and there’s also an excellent band led by music director Stephen Schermitzler. My only major issue with the show is in sound, since there are several moments in which it is difficult to make out the words to the songs over the music. I could still follow the show because I know it well, but I’m wondering how difficult it would have been for those who aren’t as familiar with the songs. I’m hoping this aspect of the show will be improved as the run continues.
Overall, despite the one quibble with the sound, this Sweeney Todd is a chilling, well-acted and well-sung success. It manages to keep the tone right throughout, and features a truly fantastic cast. It also makes the most of its space at the Greenfinch and brings the audience close to the action, adding to the creepy tone of the production. It’s an impressive showing from a great cast and crew.
Fly North Theatricals is presenting Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street at Greenfinch Theater & Dive until August 9, 2026























