Jagged Little Pill
Lyrics by Alanis Morissette, Music by Alani Morissette and Glen Ballard, Book by Diablo Cody
Directed by Brittanie Gunn
Choreographed by Ella Drake and Ruben Medina
Tesseract Theatre
July 11, 2026

Cast of Jagged Little Pill
Photo: Tesseract Theatre
Although I’m somewhat familiar with Alanis Morissette’s music, I’m not an avid fan, so Jagged Little Pill as a musical isn’t something I was necessarily eager to see. Still, as staged by Tesseract Theatre under the direction of Brittanie Gunn, it does more than serve as a vehicle for Morissette’s music. It tells a fascinating tale featuring relatable characters played by a first-rate cast, creating a believable world and thought-provoking situations.
The story has a lot going on, especially for one family all at the same time, but it’s theatre so for the most part, it works. Mary Jane Healy (Loren Goudreau) prides herself in her organization skills and her family, especially her oldest son, Nick (Stephen Henley), who just got into Harvard. Second child Frankie (Kinya Kairigi) frequently feels like second best, both as an adoptee and as an activist for causes her mom doesn’t seem to approve of. Dad Steve (Kevin O’Brien) is a workaholic who also feels like Mary Jane doesn’t give him much attention anymore. Also, at school, Frankie meets new student Phoenix (Jabari Boykin) and is attracted, much to the chagrin of her longterm friend/romantic partner Jo (Milo Garlich). Also, Nick finds himself in a dilemma when he witnesses something highly disturbing at a party involving his friend Bella (Lauren Tenenbaum). The events involve various issues that may be disturbing to some viewers, including frank talk about sex and sexuality, as well as violence and drug addiction.
Even with so much going on, the characters are developed well, and the Morissette songs–including some new ones–are incorporated credibly into the story. The acting and singing is strong all around, although some sound issues occasionally make the lyrics difficult to discern. The cast is great, led by Goudreau in a strong turn as the perfectionist Mary Jane, who finds herself in a struggle she couldn’t predict, and Kairigi as the determined Frankie, who finds herself in the middle of a love triangle while also competing for her parents’ attention. Henley is also strong as the “perfect son” Nick, and Garlich is especially strong as Jo, getting to sing the well-known “You Oughta Know” with ferocity and strength. Tenenbaum, as Bella, is also excellent, and the ensemble is also strong, with energy and good vocals, executing the memorable choreography by Ella Drake and Ruben Medina with enthusiasm and style.
The look of the show works well for the story and tone, with a fantastic, versatile set by Todd Schaefer that utilizes movable set pieces to excellent effect. There’s also great work by lighting designer Kevin Bowman and sound designer Phillip Evans. There’s also a great band led by music director Leah Schultz, doing justice to the hard-driving Morissette soundtrack.
Jagged Little Pill is a well-told story, for the most part, and it’s fascinating from start to finish, with well-defined characters and great performances. It’s a treat for Morissette fans, especially, I would think. It’s another excellent musical from Tesseract.
Tesseract Theatre is presenting Jagged Little Pill at the Marcelle until July 26, 2026






















