Primary Trust
by Eboni Booth
Directed by Tyrone Phillips
Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
February 6, 2026

Ronald L. Conner, Gregory Fenner, Alan Knoll
Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis’s latest production is a profound theatrical experience. There’s no other way to say it. Primary Trust, the Pulitzer Prize-winning play by Eboni Booth, is being given an artfully crafted, impeccably acted, and expertly designed production at the Rep, thoughtfully directed by Tyrone Phillips and featuring a truly stellar leading performance. It’s a timely play that speaks a lot to issues of connection, community, mental health, and overall kindness and understanding.
This is a story that wears its emotion on its sleeve, as 38-year-old Kenneth (Gregory Fenner) narrates the story of his life and daily routine, set in the fictional Rochester suburb of Cranberry, New York. Kenneth tries to keep the mood upbeat as he talks about his relationship with his mother, who died when he was young, and his longtime job at a bookstore run by the friendly Sam (Alan Knoll), and his daily visits to Happy Hour at local tiki bar Wally’s, where a succession of waiters (all played by Kierra Bunch) greet him and serve their signature Mai Tai cocktails. He seems relatively satisfied with his routine of working and hanging out at Wally’s with his best friend, Bert (Ronald L. Conner)–who isn’t exactly what you might think. Soon, events transpire which push Kenneth out of his comfort zone, as he finds himself needing a new job and friendly new Wally’s server Corinna (Bunch) suggests he apply at a local bank, Primary Trust, that’s in need of tellers. Kenneth is nervous in the interview, but the bank manager, Clay (Knoll) takes a liking to him, and Kenneth soon finds himself in a rapidly changing new environment where he discovers new talents and interests and has to face some uncomfortable truths about himself and the routine to which he had been accustomed.
The tone of the show is largely comic, but with a strong undercurrent of pathos, as Kenneth deals with anxiety, loneliness, and an increasingly obvious need for connection and understanding. Kenneth is the show’s center and heart, with the characters around him representing a sense of welcome and kindness that he obviously needs. It’s a thoughtful, brilliantly scripted and characterized ode to the increasingly common crisis of connection in modern society, as well as touching on issues of mental health, found family and a need for a sense of purpose in life.
The cast is first-rate, led by a truly remarkable portrayal by Fenner of the likable, insistently upbeat but struggling Kenneth. Fenner brings an amiable relatability and palpable sense of urgency to Kenneth as he navigates the rapidly changing realities of his world. There’s humor, sensitivity, and warmth to Fenner’s performance. The rest of the cast lends excellent support, with special kudos to Bunch for portraying a wide variety of waiters and bank customers with impressive versatility, as well as the personable Corinna. Knoll is also strong as important “boss” characters Sam and Clay, and Conner makes a great “sounding board” for Kenneth as the supportive Bert. There’s also excellent musical accompaniment from composer and onstage musician Jermaine Manor.
The world of the play is meticulously crafted and presented through means of the whimsical and creative set by Sotirios Livaditis, cleverly representing the “upside down town” that Kenneth inhabits, especially at first. There’s also excellent work from lighting designer Jason Lynch and sound designer Connor Wang in maintaining the overall atmosphere of the story. The costumes by Shevaré Perry are also well-suited to the characters and tone of the production.
The Rep has had an excellent season so far, but this is my favorite of their mainstage shows. Primary Trust is such an insightful, well-scripted, and ultimately uplifting show. I can see why it won a Pulitzer Prize. And at the Rep, the casting–and especially the fantastic Fenner–couldn’t be better. This is a play not to be missed.
The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis is presenting Primary Trust until March 1, 2026
















