Myth of the Ostrich
by Matt Murray
Directed by Jane Paradise
Upstream Theater
January 23, 2026

Wendy Renée Greenwood, Jenelle Gilreath Owens, Pamela Reckamp
Photo by Patrick Huber
Upstream Theater
Myth of the Ostrich is a fast-paced comic play by Canadian playwright Matt Murray that Upstream Theater’s artistic director Philip Boehm decided to stage after seeing a production in Warsaw, Poland. Fittingly, the show is part of Upstream’s season themed “When Worlds Collide”, which applies both to Boehm’s discovery of the play and its plot. Directed with a perceptive eye toward pacing and characterization by Jane Paradise, the show features excellent timing and a first-rate cast that brings life and much laughter and heart to a plotline that, while not exactly unique, highlights empathy and insight in the midst of the riotous laughter.
The basic setup isn’t new–it’s the familiar formula of disparate characters from different backgrounds being brought together and each learning something about one another and about themselves. Here, we meet Holly (Wendy Renée Greenwood), a writer from Boston and single mom who is struggling with her latest project. She’s suddenly interrupted by an unexpected visit from Pam (Jenelle Gilreath Owens), who is seeking to meet Holly, since Pam’s son Evan has been spending a lot of time with Holly’s kid, and Pam’s snooping in her son’s room has led her to believe they’re more than just friends. Holly, who knows Evan well but hasn’t met Pam, is surprised when the Wisconsin-transplant and very “traditional”, devout Catholic Pam reveals that she doesn’t know quite as much as she thinks she knows. While Holly tries to deal with the communication mix-ups, her brash best friend Cheryl (Pamela Reckamp) shows up, bearing “treats” and full of crass stories and language that make the already nervous Pam even more uncomfortable, and makes the situation even more awkward for Holly. Soon, while it’s been heavily implied that Cheryl’s baked goods are more than just ordinary snacks, Pam–who has been craving sugar after having cut it out of her diet for two weeks–hasn’t picked up on the hints, and is tempted to try one. What ensues is an energetic blend of physical comedy, awkwardness, revelations, and surprising bonding moments that demonstrate the importance of empathy and communication while also providing memorable characters and outrageous laughter from start to finish.
The cast is simply fantastic. All three characters are perfectly cast. Greenwood, as Holly, is the most “down to earth” of the three, portraying Holly’s gruff-but-caring personality with admirable restraint, as much of the character’s personality is revealed in reacting to the others’ more over-the-top moments, while also trying to maintain composure. Reckamp is a hoot as the crass and mischievous Cheryl. Her bond with Holly is obvious from the beginning, portraying a credible friendship, and the contrast with Owens’s initially more stuffy, naive Pam adds to much of the play’s humor. Owens is a scene-stealer as Pam, providing a layered characterization that rises above stereotypes, revealing a loneliness to Pam’s character–and increasing frustration with her unseen lawyer husband–to whom she talks on the phone–as well as more surprises and a marvelous flair for physical comedy as the story plays out. All three performers work together well, displaying strong ensemble energy and enthusiasm, as well as excellent timing, adding much humor as well as believable emotion as the story moves on to a somewhat abrupt but essentially satisfying conclusion.
The atmosphere of the play is well-maintained by means of Patrick Huber’s detailed, “lived-in” set and Michele Friedman Siler’s excellent costumes, which suit the characters ideally. There’s also strong work from sound designer Ellie Schwetye, and lighting designer Denisse Chavez. Although there was an announcement prior to opening that there was some trouble with the lights, whatever the issue was didn’t detract from the show or the overall atmosphere and mood. There’s also admirable work from dialect coach Lauren Roth, as the Wisconsin and Boston accents sound credible and consistent.
This is a fun show, with lots of outrageous comedy, as well as real credible connections and emotion. It’s not an all-ages show, with strong language, drug references and frank talk about sex, so that’s worth keeping in mind. Myth of the Ostrich is ultimately a character driven, energetic show that addresses some timely issues and serves as an excellent showcase for a truly great cast.
Upstream Theater is presenting Myth of the Ostrich at the Marcelle Theatre until February 8, 2026
















