The Mercy Seat
by Neil LaBute
Directed by John Pierson
St. Louis Actors’ Studio
September 13, 2026

Kelley Schnider, Franklin Killian
Photo by Patrick Huber
St. Louis Actors’ Studio
St. Louis Actors’ Studio is starting their new season with a play set against the backdrop of one of America’s greatest tragedies, but its focus is more intimate. Looking at a relationship between a man and woman affected by the tragedy, Neil LaBute’s The Mercy Seat draws into focus issues of moral dilemmas, human nature, and the consequences of owning up to the truth. It’s a well-constructed script that serves as a showcase for two first-rate performances.
The story takes place in New York City on September 12, 2001. Abby (Kelly Schnider) returns to her apartment after running out for what groceries she could find, finds a stunned Ben (Franklin Killian) sitting on the couch, ignoring a perpetually ringing cell phone. We learn that these two have been having an affair for some time, Ben is married with kids, and both apparently worked at the World Trade Center, but were not there for the attacks because they were at Abby’s place for a rendezvous. What ensues is a 90-minute back-and-forth conversation about an idea Ben has to take advantage of the tragedy for their benefit, and Kelly’s hesitance to go along with the plan. It’s a well-structured script that reveals much about the characters of both Ben and Abby throughout, raising the perpetual questions of why these two are even together in the first place, and whether they will really go through with what Ben is proposing.
The acting is what brings the drama here. The two leads are especially well chosen, with Killian painting a complex but not exactly likable portrait of a somewhat self-absorbed Ben, who seems to automatically assume Abby will go along with his idea despite her reasonable objections. Schnider is also excellent as the highly conflicted Abby, who clearly loves Ben but is realizing things about him that she’s not too happy with. The conflict and interplay between these characters is the play, essentially, and setting it around 9/11 brings out even more tension and drama knowing that a bigger crisis is going on “out there” while these two deal with their own issues and dilemmas. It’s an intriguing idea, and the setting serves as a way to reveal the truth of these characters’ inner motives in an immediate, intense way.
The scene is set well, with Patrick Huber’s detailed set and excellent lighting providing an air of authenticity to the time period and situation, as do Teresa Doggett’s well-designed costumes. There’s also strong work from sound designer John Pierson, who also directed the show with thoughtfulness and excellent pacing. The show uses the space at the Gaslight Theater particularly well, serving as an ideal backdrop for the confrontation that ensues.
This isn’t a long show, but a lot happens in 90 minutes, and the characters are well-drawn an especially well portrayed. It’s not easy to like Ben particularly, but that makes sense the way the story plays out. It’s an intriguing story featuring two strong performers, and a good start to STLAS’s new season.
St. Louis Actors’ Studio is presenting The Mercy Seat at the Gaslight Theater until September 27, 2026


















