The Thanksgiving Play
by Larissa Fasthorse
Directed by Dani Mann
West End Players Guild
November 13, 2026

Colleen Backer, Chelsie Johnston, Chuck Winning, W. Smith III
Photo by John Lamb
West End Players Guild
It’s Thanksgiving time again! It’s time for turkey and other “celebratory” food, family visits, and revisiting the complicated history of the holiday. That last part is the main focus of Larissa Fasthorse’s The Thanksgiving Play, which is currently being staged by West End Players Guild under the direction of Dani Mann. I’ve seen this play before, and remember it being especially funny and challenging. This production is both of those things, featuring an energetic cast and inventive production values. It’s a sharp satire with a lot to think, and laugh, about.
The characters are, to a certain degree, “types” many have seen before–well-meaning liberal artists who agonize over getting everything “right” in terms of cultural representation. Logan (Colleen Backer), a high school drama director, and her actor-partner Jaxton (W. Smith III) are working on a “culturally sensitive” Thanksgiving play for elementary school kids, and Logan has made a concerted effort to include a Native American point of view by hiring Alicia (Chelsie Johnston), a Los Angeles based actress, on the basis of a series of headshots and a Zoom interview. It turns out that Alicia isn’t exactly what Logan was expecting, and that throws a wrench into the plan. There’s also Caden (Chuck Winning), a history teacher who has been hired to be a consultant, but has apparently written a whole script himself, since he’s had a long-standing dream of being a playwright. He also has some historical information that’s not exactly kid-friendly.
In their increasingly desperate efforts to construct a play that represents Native American voices and is historically accurate while being appropriate for children, the group becomes increasingly frustrated and determined, leading to some truly hilarious and cringeworthy moments. These characters are so well-defined that you might even recognize them from real life, although aspects of their personalities are exaggerated. In the meantime, there are also some hilarious and occasionally disturbing projection sequences–designed by Dan Foster–that punctuate the narrative. These sequences serve increasingly to challenge modern views of the origins of Thanksgiving, providing much to consider. It’s a well-constructed script and excellently paced.
Acting-wise, the casting is fantastic. Led by Backer as the over-earnest, constantly determined Logan and Smith as the “sensitive”, Yoga-loving, somewhat defensive actor Jaxton, the comic and satirical tone of the show is expertly maintained. There is also an excellent turn from Johnston as the unashamed LA performer Alicia, who is not only aware of her stereotypical qualities, but is proud of them. Winning rounds out the cast with a marvelously quirky performance as the “history-nerd” and wannabe playwright Caden, who is determined to have his dialogue represented in the show. These four work together with expert timing and energy, adding to the madcap comic nature of the show as situations grow all the more wacky as the story plays out.
The visual aspects of the play add to the humor and wackiness, with a realistic classroom set by Rob Lippert serving as an ideal backdrop for the action. There’s also strong work from lighting designer Nathan Schroeder, projection designer Foster, and scenic paint and prop designer Katie Orr. The costumes by director Dani Mann are well-suited to the characters and add to the tone of the show. There are also some striking blood effects by Anna Blair.
The Thanksgiving Play isn’t your usual holiday story, but it’s not trying to be. It’s holding up our traditions to scrutiny, as well as the good intentions of people who seemingly want to do the right thing, but then get lost in the process. It’s a hilarious show, and it can be easy to laugh at these characters, but the show is also pointing a finger at its audience–particularly its white audience. There’s a lot to think about here, as well as much to laugh about. It’s an intelligent work of satire that works well for this time of year.

Colleen Backer, Chelsie Johnston, Chuck Winning, W. Smith III
Photo by John Lamb
West End Players Guild
West End Players Guild is presenting The Thanksgiving Play at Union Avenue Christian Church until November 22, 2026

















