Extremities
by William Mastrosimone
Directed by Gary F. Bell
August 8, 2026

Andrew Woodard, Claire Coffey, Lynett Vallejo, Lisa Hinrichs
Photo: Stray Dog Theatre
I didn’t enjoy Extremities at Stray Dog Theatre. That’s not because it’s a bad production. In fact, it’s a very well-done production, with a well-chosen cast and effective, suspenseful staging by director Gary F. Bell. Still, this isn’t the kind of play that boils down to whether you “like” it or not, because the subject matter it deals with is unpleasant to say the least. It’s a show you can admire in a sense, but at least for me, it’s not something I can use the word “enjoy” about.
The story focuses on Marjorie (Claire Coffey), a single woman who shares a home with two housemates, but she is alone when the play begins. Soon, an intruder, Raul (Andrew Woodard) arrives and attempts to assault her, but she manages to get the upper hand and trap him in the fireplace. Eventually, her housemates Terry (Lisa Hinrichs) and Patricia (Lynett Vallejo) arrive, and a debate ensues about what to do with Raul. The ensuing conversations, in which Raul pleads his own case while the others deliberate, is incredibly uncomfortable to watch. It deals with issues that are still dealt with today, but in a very early 1980s way, showing that the approach to some topics has changed in the past 40 years, but not others. There are also some graphic scenes that can be difficult to watch for some audience members. It’s all well-constructed, and the fact that it makes me so uncomfortable is a “good” thing in terms of playwriting and staging, because it all seems too real in places. Still, it’s hard to watch, at least for me.
The casting is excellent all around. Coffey as Marjorie is believable in conveying a mixture of anger, fear, and assertiveness, and Woodard is appropriately creepy and wheedling as Raul. Vallejo as the “reasonable” Patricia and Hinrichs as the more timid Terry, who is hiding a secret of her own, are also excellent, and the combination of all four personalities and goals makes for suspenseful drama. There’s also strong work from intimacy/combat choreographer Liss Fischel in lending credibility to some of the more challenging scenes here.
The set by Rob Lippert is well crafted and somewhat unique. I was given a note with the program explaining the symbolism involved in the “fragmented, broken-wood” set representing fractured emotions and an unstable world. It’s especially effective and adds to the drama. There’s also good work from lighting designer Tyler Duenow and sound designer Justin Been in adding to the overall suspenseful tone of the show, and the costumes by Gary F. Bell suit the characters well.
Extremities is a thoroughly effective production, but it’s not a pleasant show. For me, I can admire the craftmanship that goes into a show like this, but it’s not particularly easy to sit through. If you like dark, suspenseful dramas with difficult subject matter, this is the show for you, but if this kind of thing makes you uncomfortable, you may want to avoid this one. It’s certainly an exercise in theatrical boldness for Stray Dog Theatre.
Stray Dog Theatre is presenting Extremities at Tower Grove Abbey until August 22, 2026






















