A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
Music and Lyrics by Stephen Sondheim
Book by Burt Shevelove and Larry Gelbart
Based on the plays of Plautus
Directed by Scott Miller and Chris Kernan
Choreographed by Chris Kernan
New Line Theatre
June 3, 2023

Kent Coffel (center) and Cast of A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
Photo by Jill Ritter Lindberg
New Line Theatre
New Line Theatre’s latest production is of a well-known show, featuring a score by a legendary composer and a book by two veteran comedy writers. A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, based on the works of ancient Roman playwright Plautus, was a hit in the 1960s and has been performed in various venues since then. It does have its dated elements, but at New Line, as usual, there are some new perspectives that emerge. For the most part, this is a show that revels in its humor, and at New Line, the focus is on the strong singing of Stephen Sondheim’s memorable score.
The story is framed as a performance by a dramatic troupe that decides, for this day’s performance, they will be staging a comedy. What results is a slapstick farce set in Roman times, centering on Pseudolus (Kent Coffel), who is a slave in one of the three houses featured in the story. He serves Hero (Ian McCreary), the son of Senex (Robert Doyle), who is heading out of town with his controlling wife Domina (Ann Hier Brown) to visit her family. While they are away, Pseudolus works on a plan to gain his freedom after he notices that Hero has fallen for a young woman he’s seen in the window of the neighboring house, which is essentially a brothel operated by Marcus Lycus (Jason Blackburn). Soon, they find out that the object of Hero’s ardor, the virginal Philia (Sarah Wilkinson), has been purchased sight unseen by the narcissistic general Miles Gloriosus (Danny Brown), who is due to arrive soon to make her his bride. Pseudolus’s plan gets more complicated as the story goes on, much to the frustration of Senex’s chief slave Hysterium (Chris Moore), who reluctantly gets brought into the scheme. Meanwhile, the elderly Erroneus (Gary Cox), who lives in the other neighboring house, returns to town after a long absence, still looking for his long-lost children who were captured by pirates years previously. How all these stories fit together is the source of much of the comedy, which is portrayed here by an enthusiastic cast who are all in excellent voice.
I had seen this show once before, at the Muny a few years ago. Obviously, a small company like New Line isn’t going to have the elaborate production values or huge stage of the Muny, but New Line has become adept at scaling shows down for its venue, as well as bringing out nuances in stories that bigger productions can gloss over. You could say that there isn’t much room for nuance in a show like Forum, with its broad, bawdy comedy and plot that relies on old standard devices like mistaken identity and mixed-up romance, but while it’s still a broad farce, I found myself looking differently at some of the characters here, such as Domina, who comes across here much better than her lecherous husband, Senex. The dated features of the story are here, with the women being the focus of the jokes much of the time, but the overall silliness here takes precedence, for the most part.
In terms of performances, the cast is especially strong vocally, as is usual for New Line. As for comic timing, some are better than others, and there are moments when the jokes don’t land as they should, but for the most part, it’s a very funny show. Coffel as Pseudolus is ideally cast, with a strong voice and great stage presence and comic ability. Moore as Hysterium also has some memorable comic moments, as do Danny Brown as the self-admiring Miles Gloriosus, and Ann Hier Brown as the domineering but lovesick Domina. McCreary and Wilkinson are well-matched as the wide-eyed lovers, Hero and Philia. There’s also a trio of “Proteans” for an ensemble (Nathan Hakenwerth, Brittany Kohl Hester, and Aarin Kamphoefner) who all play various roles and seem to be having a great time.
The look of the production is lively and vibrant, with a brightly painted, cartoonish set by Dr. Rob Lippert, and well-styled, colorful costumes by Eileen Engel that help to set the whimsical Roman tone of the show. There’s also good work on lighting by Matt Stuckel and music direction from Joe Simpson, with a strong onstage band conducted by keyboardist Matt Kauzlarich.
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum is an unapologetic comedy that revels in its silliness. Although it’s based on plays from ancient Rome, the overall tone has a 1960s comedy vibe. New Line’s production is a lot of fun, with its small scale again working in its favor. It’s an enjoyable production especially for fans of Stephen Sondheim, goofy comedy, and great singing.
New Line Theatre is presenting A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum at the Marcelle Theatre until June 24, 2023