The Rocky Horror Show
Book, Music, and Lyrics by Richard O’Brien
Directed by Scott Miller and Chris Moore
Choreographed by Chelsie Johnston
February 28, 2025

Katie Orr, Bee Mecey, Tori Shea Cole, Rafael DaCosta, Chelsie Johnston
Photo by Jill Ritter Lindberg
New Line Theatre
The Rocky Horror Show is a cult hit with a life of its own, having spawned a perhaps more well-known film and gathered a legion of fans over the last 50+ years. Especially if you’re into dark, campy, raunchy homages of old B-style sci-fi and horror, or if you’re curious to see what everyone has been talking about, this show is worth seeing at least once. At New Line, the production is apparently taking a “back to basics” approach that is focused on capturing the independent, small-theatre vibe that the original stage show had back when it first opened. For the most part, this approach works, especially with the talented cast, simple-but-effective production values and overall horror-comedy vibe, although I do think the campiness could benefit from being turned up a notch in places.
After an introduction that sets the tone by calling back memories of old sci-fi/horror films, the story starts in “earnest” as we meet Brad (Rafael DaCosta) and Janet (Brittany Kohl, an overly perky, “innocent” newly engaged young couple. When their tires blow out on a trip to visit their old teacher Dr. Scott (Christopher Strawhun), they seek out a nearby castle to use their phone, and are led into a world weirder than their wildest dreams. Dr. Frank N. Furter (Todd Schaefer), a corset-and-fishnets clad self-described “Sweet Transvestite” is the proprietor of this castle, attended by cohorts Riff-Raff (Bee Mecey), Magenta (Katie Orr), and Columbia (Tori Shea Cole). Frank is working on a new project, a scantily-clad, muscular “Creature” known as Rocky Horror (Zachary Thompson), while Riff-Raff and Magenta keep dropping hints of an extraterrestrial origin and a desire to go back “home”. Meanwhile, Brad and Janet are given an unexpected “awakening” of sorts and are compelled to participate in a “floor show”.
There isn’t much plot here, really, since this show is more about concept and camp than plot. It’s about the vibe and the aesthetic, which at times can be a little underdone here, compared to the previous version of this show I have seen (I haven’t seen the film). The cast is generally enthusiastic, with terrific performances especially by DaCosta and Kohl–who turn in strong comic performances–and Shaefer, who hams it up with a touch of menace as Frank. There’s also strong ensemble energy by everyone else, including Chelsie Johnston as the Narrator. As is usual for New Line, there’s great singing as well, although there are moments when the sound isn’t clear, and one full song–“Eddie’s Teddy”, in which Dr. Scott tells the backstory for Frank’s earlier “project” character, the doctor’s nephew Eddie (also Strawhun)–where the harmonies sound nice, but I couldn’t understand the words, and I was sitting in the front row. The rest of the songs are fairly clear, though, and some numbers like the well-known “The Time Warp” are full of energy and excellently sung and choregraphed by Johnston. The New Line Band, led by music director Randon Lane, does a good job on the show’s catchy score, although there are a few moments when they tend to drown out the singers.
The look of the show is a bit more subdued than I have seen before, but it works, with a simple set by Rob Lippert that features a central runway and a series of microphones, almost suggesting a concert-like atmosphere. The lighting by Jack Kalan is terrific, maintaining just the right mood and vibe, and Eric Goodenough’s costumes are colorful and eye-catching, contributing a stylish air to the overall early 70s and sci-fi/horror theme of the show.
Overall, if you love Rocky Horror, you should enjoy this show. Even though there are times when it seems a bit subdued, for the most part it’s a weird, wild ride of a show. Also, while direct audience participation (like for the film) is discouraged, the audience was enthusiastic, with some attending dressed up for the occasion. This is the second show in a season of repeat productions for New Line, and it entertains with energy and campy, creepy style.

Tori Shea Cole, Todd Schaefer, Brittany Kohl, Rafael DaCosta
Photo by Jill Ritter Lindberg
New Line Theatre
New Line Theatre is presenting The Rocky Horror Show at the Marcelle Theatre until March 22, 2025

