First Impressions
An Adaptation of Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
Adapted by Ellie Schwetye
Directed by Ellie Schwetye & Rachel Tibbetts
PPA Alumni Theatre Company and SATE Ensemble Theatre
February 12, 2026
Image: SATE and Prison Performing Arts
SATE and PPA Alumni Theatre Company recently offered audiences another impression of the award-winning Jane Austen-inspired work First Impressions at The Chapel, where SATE first debuted the show in 2017. Prison Performing Arts also staged a version at WERDCC in 2019, and video from both productions has been incorporated in the pre-show video for this latest version, billed as a “Fully Staged Reading Experience”. Although it was a reading, the staging was quite clever, and the use of actors live and on video contributed much in the way of humor and entertainment value.
The premise is the same as before–an adaptation of Austen’s most famous novel Pride and Prejudice, interspersed with reflections from the cast about their experience with the novel and its various film adaptations. It’s been revised a fair amount since I saw the production in 2017, with more personal reflections and some more references to the 2005 filmed version of the novel. I was intrigued to note that several of the performers in this iteration stated that they hadn’t read the novel before working on this show, and so this production is their true “first impression”, although several others seemed to be longtime fans of Austen and the book, and issues discussed included favorite characters, comparisons of Mr. Darcy film actors, and the plot’s relevance for today. It’s a clever idea to adjust the reflections depending on the cast, which could work for future productions, as well.
The staging is crisp and lively, with fun use of the music stands used to hold the scripts the actors are reading from. The set by Bess Moynihan, who also designed the lighting, was whimsical and fun, featuring a video “portrait” in the middle of the performance area, featuring several cast members who recorded their performances in advance, including Patty Prewett as the imperious Lady Catherine DeBourgh, Hazel McIntire as scheming Caroline Bingley, Julie Antonic as Pemberley housekeeper Mrs. Reynold’s, and an especially fun turn by LaWanda Jackson and Janiece Moore giving running commentary and billed as “Statler & Waldorf”. Autumn Hales in a dual role as fourth Bennet sister Kitty and as Mr. Darcy’s younger sister, Georgiana The live cast was enthusiastic and memorable, as well, led by the excellent turns as Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy by real-life couple Alicen Kramer-Moser and Anthony Kramer-Moser. These two worked together well, exhibiting excellent stage presence and chemistry. There were also strong impressions made by Margeau Steinau and Eric Satterfield as Mr. and Mrs. Bennet, Hailey Medrano as the sweet eldest sister Jane Bennet, Miranda Jagels-Félix in a fun turn as middle Bennet daughter Mary, and Kristen Strom as the flighty, flirty Lydia. David Nonemaker as the somewhat silly Mr. Collins, Andre Eslamian in a dual role as the kind Mr. Bingley and rakish Mr. Wickham, and Victoria Thomas as Elizabeth’s practical-minded friend Charlotte Lucas also contributed much to the wit, humor, and fun of the production.
The rest of the technical elements were also strong, with notable distinction going to Brian Dooley and David Nonemaker for their excellent videography, and Dooley and Eric Satterfield for their video editing and projection design. The costumes by Tyler White and Kayla Lindsay featured a clever blend of Regency-era influence and modern style, and Ellie Schwetye’s sound design was also strong.
This show was, and continues to be, a fitting tribute to Austen’s classic novel and its fans over the generations. It’s a lively, versatile adaptation that works well in various formats, and I can easily imagine more iterations of it in various venues in the future. The only notable drawback to this production was that it only ran for one weekend, so more people didn’t get the chance to enjoy it.