Bread and Wine’s “Babette’s Feast” Entertains with Energy and Heart

Babette’s Feast
Conceived and Developed by Abigail Kileen, Written by Rose Courtney
Adapted from the Short Story by Isak Dinesen
Directed by Owen Brown
Bread and Wine Theatre Company
in Collaboration with KTK Productions
March 27, 2026

Bread and Wine Theatre Company is producing their latest production, Babette’s Feast, in a new venue at Holy Trinity Catholic Church in Old North, in collaboration with KTK Productions, who have worked to renovate the church’s basement for their new theatre space. The production fits the space well, featuring an enthusiastic cast and striking musical elements, making for an entertaining and emotional story of generosity and grace in the midst of asceticism and interpersonal conflict.

The story is told in flashback, as narrated by the cast. While the titular Babette (Deborah Roby) eventually becomes a central figure, we don’t meet her until after a somewhat involved prologue setting up the story’s main event. We meet a devout religious community in a small Norwegian mountain town, led by a strict but loving Dean (Cole Wright) who has two daughters, Martine (Sonya Valentine), and the musically gifted Phillipa (Michelle Yoder). We see how Martine is courted by a young visitor named Loewenheilm (Michael Cox), who later reappears as a General (Charlie Labitska). Philippa, for her part, meets and takes singing lessons from renowned French opera singer Achille Papin (Ben Smith), with who she shares an attraction, but these relationships both end as the sisters choose to stay in their austere life and community. Years later, Babette appears on their doorstep, cast out from Paris and sent with a recommendation letter from Papin, who mentions that “Babette can cook”. She becomes the sisters’ housekeeper and carries herself with a determined air, eventually becoming well known in the village.  After more years pass, something happens that allow Babette to make an elaborate offer that both intrigues and frightens the sisters and the town, but eventually leads to much revelation and truth. 

It’s a fascinating story, originating as a short story by noted Danish author Isak Dinesen that was made into an acclaimed 1987 film. The stage version is well-structured and collaborative, with most of the players playing several roles, with the exception of the sisters and Babette. The narration is fairly easy to follow, except for a few of the moments in which the cast speaks in unison, which can sometimes be difficult to understand, and some of the acoustics make some dialogue difficult to hear at times. For the most part, though, the story flows well, and the characters are memorable, led by Roby’s determined Babette, who exudes a palpable blend of confidence, determination, and integrity. Valentine and Yoder are also convincing as the sisters, with Yoder’s excellent singing a particular highlight of the production. The rest of the players (also including Madeline Trinity, and Mary Elsa Henrich) fill out the story with enthusiasm and energy, and with memorable turns from Cox in various roles and Smith for his also impressive vocals. It’s a long production–almost two hours with no intermission–but the thoughtful direction and cast energy holds the audience’s attention without dragging.

The set by Tara Laurel works well on the slightly high stage, and Laurel’s costumes are appropriate to the period and setting, suiting the characters well. There’s also notable work from lighting designer Megan King and music director Nathan Wamsley. The production also included eye-catching Irish dancing from Lucy Marie and Pippa Gutting from St. Louis Irish Arts, although its inclusion in a story set in Norway and featuring no Irish characters seems a bit odd. 

Babette’s Feast is structured almost like a folk tale or poem, and it raises fascinating questions of asceticism and piety vs. generosity and indulgence, and how those concepts fit with religious devotion and community flourishing. The concepts of grace and generosity are well-embodied, and there’s much to think and talk about here. It’s also a delightfully musical show, featuring  both classical singing and congregational hymns. It’s an entertaining offering from the still relatively new Bread and Wine Theatre Company.

Bread and Wine Theatre Company is presenting Babette’s Feast in collaboration with KTK Productions at Holy Trinity Catholic Church until March 29, 2026