Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
Book by Douglas McGrath
Words & Music by Gerry Goffin & Carole King, Barry Mann & Cynthia Weil
Directed and Choreographed by Jennifer Werner
STAGES St. Louis
September 24, 2025

David Socolar, Kailey Boyle, Brianna Kothari Barnes, Jeff Cummings
Photo by Phillip Hamer
STAGES St. Louis
Seeing different productions of the same show can bring out different aspects of the show, also while highlighting the reasons why certain shows succeed so well at telling their stories on multiple levels. STAGES St. Louis’s latest offering, Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, is the third and “smallest” production I’ve seen of this show, after the touring show at the Fox a few years ago and the lavish Muny production in 2023. While all three productions have been excellent, each one seems to have its own “personality”, and this one at STAGES, under the direction of Jennifer Werner and featuring a fantastic cast, comes across as perhaps the most personal of all.
The smartly-scripted musical focuses on legendary singer-songwriter Carole King (Brianna Kothari Barnes), who started out as a Brooklyn teenager with a gift for composing music and a mother, Genie Klein (Amy Loui), who encourages her daughter to pursue a more “stable” career as a music teacher. But the talented and ambitious Carole is determined to make it as a songwriter, soon meeting publisher/producer Don Kirshner (Jeff Cummings), and selling her first song. She also meets Gerry Goffin (Sean McGee), who soon becomes her partner in both songwriting and life, as the two marry, have a baby, and eventually find success with a series of hit songs performed by popular artists like the Drifters (Ian Coulter-Buford, Trey McCoy, Devin Price, Justin Reynolds),the Shirelles (Tatiana Bahoque, Tiffany Francés, Sydney Quildon, Alexandrea Reynolds), and Little Eva (also Quildon). Carole and Gerry also become close friends and professional rivals with another couple, the songwriting team of Barry Mann (David Socolar) and Cynthia Weil (Kailey Boyle). The story follows Carole through the pop music scene of the 1960s as well as challenges in her marriage as Gerry begins to feel restless and deals with mental health and substance abuse issues, finally leading up to her emergence as a solo artist and the debut of her Grammy-winning album Tapestry and a celebrated concert at Carnegie Hall.
It’s an insightful look at the American pop music scene from the late 1950s to the early 1970s, as well as a celebration of King’s talent, personality, and artistic development. It’s also a compelling look at friendships among creative artists, and the triumphs and temptations of show business. With the more intimate staging of this production and the smaller ensemble, the personal aspects of King’s life seem to stand out more, as do the personal interaction among artists and writers. The staging is well-paced, and the cast is well-chosen, led by a charismatic and relatable Barnes, who sings in King’s style with ease and displays strong stage presence and chemistry with her co-stars, especially McGee’s charming but erratic Gerry, and the memorable standouts Boyle as Cynthia and Socolar as Barry. Cummings is also a highlight as the commercially-focused but supportive Kirshner. There’s also a first-rate ensemble playing all those superstars of yesteryear also including the Righteous Brothers (Hugh Entrekin, RJ Woessner), Neil Sedaka (Woessner), and Janelle Woods (Bahoque).
The look, sound, and vibe of the eras portrayed are marvelously well-realized, with a kinetic, eye-catching set by Peter Barbieri, dazzling lighting design by Sean M. Savoie, and excellent sound by Breanna Fais. The colorful, detailed period costumes by Cat Lovejoy also add to the overall mood and atmosphere, and there’s a great band led by music director David Nehls, bringing to life all those well-known hits including “Will You Love Me Tomorrow”, “You’ve Got a Friend”, “One Fine Day”, and many more. Werner’s choreography is also a highlight, and the staging on production numbers like the especially memorable “The Locomotion” is stellar.
Ultimately, what comes across here in an especially powerful way is the real sense of connection and friendship, with the “You’ve Got a Friend” sequence featuring Carole along with Weil, Mann, and Kirschner being a particularly heartwarming moment. Beautiful is a show that celebrates the life and work of Carole King, but also the music and eras in which she got her start. At STAGES, the show lives up to its title, highlighting the beauty of music, friendship, and creativity.
STAGES St. Louis is presenting Beautiful: The Carole King Musical at the Kirkwood Performing Arts Center until October 19, 2025








