Elsinore
by David Nonemaker and Eric Satterfield
Directed by Eric Satterfield
Chorus of Fools
October 9, 2025
Zach Pierson, Andrew Eslamian, Xander Huber
Photo by David Nonemaker
Chorus of Fools
Creating theatre is a fascinating process, and I feel blessed to have been able to witness the development of new plays over the years, including the latest production from Chorus of Fools. Elsinore, by David Nonemaker and Eric Satterfield, first premiered in a production by Prison Performing Arts Alumni Theatre Company in 2021, and I saw and reviewed that production, noting its promise and the work I thought still needed to be done. The new production, with some of the same creative team and one of the same actors, is still recognizable, but has been impressively revised and refined from that earlier iteration, emphasizing the strengths of the story and character and resulting in a more dramatically satisfying and emotionally affecting prequel to William Shakespeare’s most famous tragedy, Hamlet.
The story is told in three acts, as opposed to two acts in the previous version. Many of the characters from Hamlet are featured, along with some notable new additions, although the familiar characters start out quite differently from what you may expect. In Act 1, it’s 15 years before the events of Shakespeare’s tragedy, and the elder King Hamlet (John Wolbers) is an imperious, somewhat possessive and nervous ruler, trying to rule Denmark with an iron hand, and is dealing with disappointment in his teenage son Hamlet (Andre Eslamian), whom the elder king regards as “soft” and who is mostly interested in getting up to mischief with his buddies Rosencrantz (Xander Huber) and Guildenstern (Zach Pierson). Young Hamlet often feels closer to his uncle, Claudius (Joseph Garner), and flees to his house to avoid his father’s wrath. Claudius is an advisor to the King and is happily married to Collette (Lexie Johnson), who is expecting the couple’s third child after having lost the first two. As the king grows more jealous of his son’s bond with Claudius and deals with tension in his marriage to Gertrude (Jocelyn Padilla), Claudius comes up with an idea for how to help young Hamlet, which ultimately begins their gradual estrangement. Meanwhile, the king’s bumbling counselor Polonius (Chuck Brinkley) brings his studious daughter Ophelia (Hannah Geisz) to serve in Gertrude’s court after having returned from an unpleasant time in France. Of course, Ophelia and Hamlet develop a friendship that promises to grow into something more.
That’s just the first act. The next act jumps ahead fourteen years, and we see how the characters and relationships have grown and changed. We also see the seeds of Claudius’s resentment and ambition, and dramatic events that lead to who he becomes in Hamlet. Clever scripting and intriguing character development make for a story that blends sympathy, humor, and tragedy into a credible “before it happened” tale that makes sense as a prequel for one of the world’s best-known plays. Although this backstory isn’t quite how I would have imagined it, the playwrights have done the work to make it make sense, including allusions and parallels to the “parent play” in ways that seem natural and even poetic. The language is also believably Shakespearean, for the most part, and the characters well-developed. As before, I especially love the interactions between Hamlet and Ophelia, but I find Claudius more intriguing this time as well, and the King is a more well-rounded character, and the developments in Claudius’s family life are more thoroughly explained here.
The cast is excellent, with Garner a thoroughly convincing Claudius, who goes on a journey from sensitive younger brother/uncle and doting husband and father to ambitious wannabe monarch. Garner brings a degree of nuance to the role as well as a clear progression from sympathetic to scheming and beyond. Eslamian as Hamlet is also strong, portraying a believable sense of growth in the character and fantastic chemistry with Geisz, who is a supremely likable and intelligent Ophelia. There are also strong performances from Padilla as the increasingly conflicted Gertrude, Huber and Pierson as the mischievous Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, and Johnson as Claudius’s gentle wife Collette. Pierson also has a strong turn as Young Claudius, son of Hamlet’s uncle, and Brinkley is a scene-stealer as the bumbling but subtly scheming Polonius. Rose Reiker as Osric and Joe Kercher in several roles round out the cast, with all contributing energy and presence to this intriguing, emotionally involving story. I do somewhat wonder at the play’s somewhat smarmy characterization of Laertes (Kercher), since it doesn’t seem fitting with how the character turns out in Hamlet, but that’s a playwriting/directing issue rather than an acting issue.
The look and atmosphere of the show is notably consistent, with a setting that seems like mid-to-late 19th century in terms of costumes and sets. Celeste Gardner’s costumes are particularly outstanding, with excellent attention to detail and period, and suiting the characters well. The set by Vicki Delmas and Satterfield is also excellent, with a prominent red-and-grey color scheme and a suitably “royal” tone. There’s also good work from lighting designer Bradley Rohlf and sound designer Satterfield, and clever use of memorable music during the intermissions that goes along well with the themes of the play.
Overall, while I enjoyed Elsinore the first time I saw it, the play seems like a much more well-realized vision at this point. Featuring familiar characters and themes, and using them in intriguing and occasionally gripping ways, this is a thoroughly credible story that makes sense as a lead-up to Hamlet. It also fits well into the space at Greenfinch Theater & Dive, and includes a few “spooky” elements in keeping with Halloween season. It’s well worth seeing, and an impressive accomplishment from Chorus of Fools.
Joseph Garner, Jocelyn Padilla
Photo by David Nonemaker
Chorus of Fools
Chorus of Fools is presenting Elsinore at Greenfinch Theater & Dive until October 19, 2025
Leave a Reply