Austen’s Pride: A New Musical of Pride and Prejudice
Book, Music, and Lyrics by Lindsay Warren Baker and Amanda Jacobs
Directed by Igor Goldin
Choreographed by Lisa Shriver
STAGES St. Louis
July 30, 2025
Dan Hoy, Olivia Hernandez, Delphi Borich
Photo by Phillip Hamer
STAGES St. Louis
The latest offering from STAGES St. Louis is a pre-Broadway showcase performance, the second they’ve done after The Karate Kid three years ago, and at least for me, this effort is even more promising than the last one. I’m admittedly a big Jane Austen fan, having read her novels and seen many of the film, television, and stage adaptations. This latest new musical, though, is more than just an adaptation. Austen’s Pride: A New Musical of Pride and Prejudice, is about Austen herself as much as it is about her most well-known novel. And while there are some aspects that could use a little bit of work, for the most part it’s an intriguing, entertaining showcase for a great cast and excellent melodic score.
With book, music, and lyrics by Lindsay Warren Baker and Amanda Jacobs, Austen’s Pride starts out on a mostly dark stage, with Jane Austen (Olivia Hernandez) trying to figure out what to write next after the success of her novel Sense and Sensibility. Her devoted sister Cassandra (Dianica Phelan) suggests Jane revisit an old draft of hers, a novel called First Impressions, but Austen isn’t sure she wants to write another love story. Then she starts reading through the story and the characters appear, with Austen making changes as it goes along and reflecting on incidents from her own life which influence the story in various ways. She also interacts directly with the characters at times, especially heroine Elizabeth Bennet (Delphi Borich), as Elizabeth’s story becomes influenced by Austen’s own experiences, and Austen herself becomes affected by the story that seems to have a life of its own.
The Pride and Prejudice story is familiar to many, and all the well-known characters are here, from the lead character Elizabeth to her suitor Mr. Darcy (Dan Hoy), and her whole family, including parents Mr. Bennet (Kevyn Morrow) and Mrs. Bennet (Sally Wilfert), and sisters Jane (Addie Morales), Mary (Sarah Ellis), Kitty (Cali Noack), and Lydia (Kate Fahey). We also meet the various suitors, including the kindly, effusive Mr. Bingley (Cole Thompson), the oafish Mr. Collins (Paul Castree), and the charming but rakish Mr. Wickham (Michael Burrell). Several of the cast members also play other characters as needed, with notable examples being that Wickham’s actor also plays Austen’s former suitor Tom Lefroy, and Mrs. Bennet’s performer also plays the imperious Lady Catherine DeBourgh.
Of course there’s a lot of condensing here, and the blending of Austen’s personal life with the story is easier to follow if you know more about the author’s history. Also, some of the character cuts affect the tone of the story in ways I’m not sure work as well as they should–especially in terms of Lady Catherine, who comes across as even more unreasonable than in the book, since all reference to her daughter Anne has been removed (without even one mention), which makes Lady Catherine’s objections to Darcy’s interest in Elizabeth even more ridiculous than they are in the novel. Also, some characters seem like the writers didn’t always know what to do with them, like Cassandra, who has some excellent moments but also disappears for long stretches to the point where it’s easy to forget she was there in the first place. There’s also little suspense in whether the story will actually be finished, because we know that it was in “real life”, and some of the efforts to add conflict come across as clumsy (especially at the end of Act 1).
Still, those are issues that can be worked on, and for the most part, Austen’s Pride is an intriguing, thoroughly entertaining show, with a broadly witty sense of humor and a believable connection between Austen and her story, as well as an excellent treatment of the growing relationship between Elizabeth and Darcy. The casting is first-rate, as well, with Hernandez showing excellent presence as Austen, with a bit of a Mary Poppins vibe and marvelous vocals. Borich is also fantastic as Elizabeth, working especially well with Hernandez’s Austen and Hoy’s note-and-book perfect Mr. Darcy. The rest of the cast is also strong, with Phelan making the most of the underwritten role of Cassandra, Morrow and Wilfert memorable as Mr. and Mrs. Bennet, and all the Bennet sisters being especially well-cast. Special note goes to Ellis, who makes the most of three roles–the stuffy, socially awkward Mary Bennet, the priggish Caroline Bingley, and Elizabeth’s kindly aunt Mrs. Gardiner. Cole Thompson as Mr. Bingley, Castree as both Mr. Collins and Mr. Gardiner, and Burrell as Wickham and Tom Lefroy all give strong turns as well. It’s a strong ensemble all around, with a good deal of energy and enthusiasm in the production numbers and dances choreographed by Lisa Shriver with a fun blend of Regency styles and modern Broadway flair.
The set and technical aspects of the show are deceptively simple, with little in the way of actual set pieces and a lot being done with lighting and projections. Josh Zangen’s set is notable for its economy, with a few furniture pieces that move on and off as needed, and excellent projected backdrops. Jason Lyons’s lighting adds much to the atmosphere and whimsical quality of much of the story, and Phillip Peglow’s sound is crisp and clear. There’s also excellent work from Emily Rebholz on the marvelously detailed costumes, and by Tommy Kurzman on wig and hair design. The orchestra, led by music director Sheela Ramesh, is in fine form, as well, lending a lush sound to the sweeping new score by Baker and Jacobs.
Ultimately, there’s much to love about Austen’s Pride, even if aspects of it could stand some revision. Especially for Jane Austen fans, this is a fun, fascinating story. It also works as a great showcase for it’s talented cast, and especially its leads, Hernandez and Borach. It’s a promising show given a memorable staging at STAGES St. Louis.
Cast of Austen’s Pride
Photo by Phillip Hamer
STAGES St. Louis
STAGES St. Louis is presenting Austen’s Pride at the Kirkwood Performing Arts Center until August 24, 2025