A Christmas Short Play Festival
Bread and Wine Theatre Company
December 6, 2025
Bo Hanley, Peter D’Alessio
Haley Clegg, Laura Kyro
Photo by Roger Ottwell
Bread and Wine Theatre Company
Bread and Wine Theatre Company is a newer face on the St. Louis theatre scene, expressing a mission to “create innovative productions that highlight the beauty of a virtuous life”, according to CEO Owen Brown, who also directs one of the plays in their inaugural Christmas Short Play Festival. Held in a somewhat unusual venue, the Historic Sappington House, the festival features five plays and a cast of local performers. It’s an intriguing way to get to “know” a new theatre company while also exploring themes of love, loss, compassion, family–both biological and found, and the passage of time.
The first and longest play of the evening is by celebrated playwright Thornton Wilder. “The Long Christmas Dinner”, directed by Brown, shows a family holiday gathering over the course of 90 years, starting in the 1840s and ending around 1930. The conceit is that it plays out showing the passage of time as one continuous gathering, starting early in the marriage of Roderick I (Adam Usry) and Lucia I (Haley Clegg), as they share a holiday meal with his mother, Mother Bayard (Bo Hanley). Over the course of the story, the conversation never stops, but characters grow old, get up and leave through a black curtain (apparently symbolizing death), as new characters enter, the family increases and decreases, and characters reflect on changing times and relationships. Much of the story focuses on Lucia and Roderick’s children, since from childhood to older age and played by Pietro D’Alessio as Charles and Laura Kyro as Genevieve, who join their parents and aging Cousin Brandon (Nicholas Urbanowicz), and are later joined by Charles’s wife Leonora (Tara Laurel) and their children Sam (Usry), Lucia II (Clegg), and Roderick II (Urbanowicz); and Cousin Ermengarde (Hanley). Abbey Robinson also appears as a nurse working for the family. This is a fascinating play with a strong through-line of change and the passage of time. The performances are enthusiastic, with Kyro standing out for a believable portrayal of Genevieve’s growth from childhood to adulthood. The setting in the library building at Sappington House works especially well to set the mood and tone of this production.
The rest of the plays range from the very short to about 20 minutes in length, ending with a poignant if slightly over-the-top production of Dan Neidermyer’s adaptation of O. Henry’s classic “The Gift of the Magi”, directed by Travis Pfeifer. Michael Cox and Livy Potthoff are endearing as newlyweds Jim and Della, who struggle to find gifts for each other as they prepare to celebrate their first Christmas as a married couple. Bruce Jehling also appears in two roles, as Jim’s boss and as a shopkeeper.
The festival also features Cox in the title role of “Bosco’s Xmas” by Carol W. Berman, also directed by Pfeifer. This is a very short sketch about a cat, memorably played in a physically animated performance by Cox, who is seeking “revenge” by attacking his family’s Christmas tree.
The remaining two plays are directed by Chandler Spradling. “The Last Mall Santa” by Michael Cox features Jodan Matt-Zeitler as Pete, a melancholy mall Santa who is reflecting on his time in this role, as his mall is undergoing difficult times and is about to close. The staging is clever here, as we see Pete interact with various toys that slide in from offstage, “playing” the roles of children who visit Santa. Pete grows sadder and more discouraged until his final visitor appears, this time played by a real child and aptly named Hope (Riley Shelembauer). It’s a poignant look at changing times and seasons, and the importance of hope.
“Baked Alaska” by Kelli Lynn Woodend features a group of guys from a rehab facility–Jeb (John Emery), Vigil (Connor Malone), and Clementine (Matt-Zeitler) being taken on a shopping trip by Freida (Hannah Lindsey) to buy Christmas gifts for their kids. It’s a little rough around the edges, but the message of kindness in hard times comes through clearly, making for a memorable sentiment.
The location and seating arrangement adds much in the way of intimacy to the proceedings here, and although some of the performances are uneven, the Christmas spirit–in various forms–is palpable. It’s an intriguing look at a new theatre company with potential. I’m curious to see what else they bring in the future.
Bread and Wine Theatre Company is presenting A Christmas Short Play Festival at the Historic Sappington House until December 13, 2025