Deceived
Based on the play Gaslight by Patrick Hamilton
Adapted by Johnna Wright and Patty Jamieson
Directed by Sharon Hunter
Moonstone Theatre Company
October 15, 2026

Rhiannon Creighton, Cooper Shaw, Aaron Orion Baker, Christina Yancy
Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Moonstone Theatre Company
After a hiatus of over two years, Moonstone Theatre Company has returned with a new show and an aptly named new venue. It’s amusing to note that their new production, which is based on Patrick Hamilton’s Gaslight, is being staged at the Gaslight Theater. This version, called Deceived, adapted by Johnna Wright and Patty Jamieson and directed by Sharon Hunter, is more chilling than amusing. Performed by a strong cast and featuring excellent technical elements, this is a fascinating adaptation that plays out differently than the original version, all for the better in terms of storytelling and the main character’s agency.
The story, which spawned a famous term for a kind of psychological manipulation, has also been adapted into two films, the more famous of which–made in 1944–featured Ingrid Bergman, Charles Boyer, and Angela Lansbury, although it was fairly loosely based on the play, which this version more closely follows, to a point. I’ve seen the original play (also known as Angel Street) a few years ago, and it’s fun to compare the different versions. This version removes one character, police officer Rough, and focuses more attention on the women of the play, allowing Bella (Christina Yancy) more personal agency in her own story. The setup is the same, with Bella and her husband Jack (Aaron Orion Baker) having settled into a well-appointed London townhouse with a disturbing past history, while Jack goes about his secretive “business” and Bella stays home most of the time, feeling increasingly disturbed by recurring events and missing objects that she doesn’t remember moving. Jack expresses concern about Bella’s mental health to their kindly housekeeper Elizabeth (Cooper Shaw) and hires a somewhat defiant new maid, Nancy (Rhiannon Creighton) to help around the house, but his “concern” for his wife seems more and more like control as the story goes on. Strange noises, Jack’s mysterious trips out and about, and the disappearance of her mother’s prized pearls cause Bella to question the situation, and herself, and the people around her all the more, leading to a great deal of suspense and a dramatic confrontation.
It’s a fantastic adaptation, giving the Bella character more to do and puts the primary burden of figuring out what’s happening on her shoulders, providing an excellent acting showcase for the terrific Yancy, who portrays Bella’s range of emotions with impeccable veracity. Yancy goes from the somewhat naive and disturbed Bella into an increasing more bold and curious character as the show goes on, and her scenes with the equally strong Baker as the increasingly creepy Jack are a highlight of the show. There are also strong performances from Shaw as the sympathetic, protective Elizabeth and Creighton as the somewhat edgy, secretive Nancy. All of the women are given well-rounded portrayals especially, showing more background behind their motivations than in the original version of the play.
The play, set in 1901, has achieved a vivid and credible look and feel, by means of Katherine Stepanek’s well-appointed set, including ever-present gaslights. Theresa Doggett’s costumes are meticulously crafted and true to the period and characters, as well. The lighting by Ethan Steimel and Eve Garty, and the sound by Amanda Werre, are especially striking, lending much suspense to the overall chilling atmosphere of the show.
Deceived is a riveting, suspenseful drama, and a showcase for a stellar cast of local performers who give their roles all the energy and presence required, and more. It’s not exactly horror, but it fits in with the spooky tone of a lot of the shows being staged this time of year. It’s got one more weekend in its run, and it’s certainly worth checking out for an intelligent, thought-provoking adaptation of a well-known story that puts the focus on the women more than ever. It’s a welcome return for Moonstone Theatre Company.
Moonstone Theatre Company is presenting Deceived at the Gaslight Theater until October 25, 2026


