Million Dollar Quartet Christmas
Book by Colin Escott
Directed by Keith Andrews
Repertory Theatre of St. Louis and STAGES St. Louis
December 6 ,2024

Cast of Million Dollar Quartet Christmas
Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Repertory Theatre of St. Louis, STAGES St. Louis
Both the Rep and STAGES St. Louis have presented the musical Million Dollar Quartet before, with STAGES’ version occurring just last season. Now, the two prominent local companies are teaming up for the first time to present the holiday-themed sequel, Million Dollar Quartet Christmas, with most of the cast from last year’s STAGES show on the Rep’s main stage at the Loretto-Hilton center for a well-cast evening of music, reflection, and yuletide cheer as the cast of (mostly) well-known characters continue their jam session with a series of popular songs and holiday favorites.
Since the “Million Dollar Quartet” of Elvis Presley (Sean Buckley), Johnny Casy (Scott Moreau), Carl Perkins (Jeremy Sevelovitz), and Jerry Lee Lewis (Brady Wease) were only brought together by producer Sam Phillips (Jeff Cummings) at the Sun Records studio in Memphis on one occasion, I wondered how a sequel would work. What book writer Colin Escott has done, however, is just to extend that “jam session” on the same night, taking place after the four posed for the famous photo. It’s December, and Christmas is approaching, so I guess it makes sense that the group would add some carols and other holiday tunes to their repertoire such as “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree”, “Go Tell It on the Mountain” and “Blue Christmas”, along with a few other hits of the day including Elvis’s “Don’t Be Cruel” and well known songs by other artists including “Que Sera, Sera”, “Hot Diggity Dog” and more. It isn’t purely a concert, though, and there is a bit of a plot, if you can call it that, as Phillips continues to express his disappointment at the artists leaving Sun Records for more glamorous contracts elsewhere, the artists stress over family commitments and other developments, and the role of Elvis’s fictional girlfriend, Dyanne (Shelby Ringdahl) has been expanded in a way that works surprisingly well, as she serves as more a catalyst for some of the events this time as well as having some memorable vocal moments with songs like “Santa Baby” and the aforementioned “Que Sera, Sera”.
It’s a fun musical experience, with a great cast returning and turning in stellar performances all around, joined by newcomer Buckley as an appropriately charismatic, vocally strong Elvis who also moves well. Sevelovitz and Zayas, as Carl and Jay Perkins, are standouts again as they were last year at STAGES, and Wease has all the electric energy that the role of Lewis requires, along with great piano skills. Moreau is solid as Cash, as well, and Ringdahl gets an impressive showcase in the slightly expanded role of Dyanne. Cummings as Phillips is also strong, although the script can make him occasionally come across as overly whiny, and there’s also strong support again from musical director Dave Sonneborn as percussionist W.S. “Fluke” Holland. This is a fun little story, but mostly it’s a jam session, and it’s all about the music, which is played very, very well, and with an additional dose of holiday spirit this time.
The set by Adam Koch is appropriately authentic-seeming, and there’s also excellent lighting by Sean M. Savoie and sound by Beef Gratz. The costumes by Brad Musgrove are suitably colorful and authentic to the characters who wear them. The late 1950’s atmosphere is well-maintained, along with the extra Christmasy elements that make this a holiday show.
Overall, Million Dollar Quartet Christmas is just about as entertaining as the first addition, coming across as something of an extended, holiday-themed encore. It’s great to see the impressive cast returning, with an excellent new addition in Buckley. What’s especially encouraging, though, is the collaborative effort of the Rep and STAGES, and I hope this won’t be the last time we see these excellent companies working together.

Brady Wease, Scott Moreau, Jeremy Sevelovitz, Shelby Ringdahl, Sean Buckley, Chuck Zayas
Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Repertory of St. Louis, STAGES St. Louis
The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis and STAGES St. Louis are presenting Million Dollar Quartet Christmas at the Loretto-Hilton Center until December 22, 2024

