Wild Nights
by Courtney Bailey
Directed by Chuck Harper and Maggie Conroy
Young Liars
May 31, 2026

Ashwini Arora, Ellie Schwetye, Keating, Frankie Ferrari
Photo by StudioKayMedia
Young Liars
You’re invited to a slumber party, and don’t forget the Brand Name Snacks! It’s 1997, although time is something of a spectrum here since our main characters are from the 19th century, as famed poet Emily Dickinson (Ashwini Arora) and her close friend and sister-in-law Sue (Ellie Schwetye) have enlisted the help of a group of 90’s teens to host an authentic sleepover with the aim of seeing the Face of God in Courtney Bailey’s hilarious new play Wild Nights. It’s also a memorable time in history, as the characters soon learn of Princess Diana’s tragic car crash and wait to learn her fate. There are also card tricks, Dr. Pepper, the “Hot Boy Report”, and personal revelations about growing up, poetry, love, life, and mortality. It’s somewhat of an odd play to figure out at times, but there’s a lot here to think about, and as produced by Young Liars under the direction of Chuck Harper and Maggie Conroy, it’s certainly a show that lives up to its title.
The set is a whimsical delight, designed by Maggie Conroy with such careful detail that creates a real “slumber party” that provides a semi-immersive element while also adding a bit of a mystical twist, in that the fridge is a sort of gateway between time periods, among other fun aspects. My slumber party days were mostly in the 80’s, but there’s a bit of a timeless vibe about sleepovers to which many in the audience obviously relate, judging by reactions on the night I saw the show. Many long-held traditions are upheld here as Emily and Sue have enlisted the help of “sleepover experts”–a group of Boston teenagers including Missy (Keating), Bernadette (Frankie Ferrari), Anoushka (Molly Burris), Donna (Conroy), and Donna’s cousin Christopher (Cassidy Flynn). With all their plans kept in a sacred Trapper Keeper, the pair–eventually joined by Emily’s sister Lavinia (Rachel Tibbetts)–embark on their journey to see the Face of God in the midst of revelations about relationships, poetry, growing up, life and death–as the news about Diana eventually gets out and is incorporated into the story. Pop culture elements like 90s music, Tomagotchis, and more are blended into the story along with Dickinson’s poetry and some memorable singing and dancing. There’s excellent work from the entire crew, including vibrant costumes by Marcy Wiegert and well-designed lighting by Bradley Rohlf and sound by Chuck Harper.
The entire cast is splendid, led by Arora and Schwetye in highly likable quirky turns as Emily and Sue, along with an especially enthusiastic Tibbetts as Lavinia. All the teens are well cast, as well, with strong turns from each, and Keating and Flynn especially standing out for their energy and emotional moments. It’s a strikingly cohesive ensemble, giving off the 90’s teen vibe with gusto, capturing the naivety and reckless energy of youth as well as a palpable sense of fear of the unknown mixed with insatiable curiosity. There’s a lot to ponder here, and Bailey’s script manages to be absolutely hilarious and remarkably thoughtful at the same time. There are a few memorable surprises here as well that I won’t spoil, but at least one of them was fairly predictable although still wonderfully appropriate.
Overall, Wild Nights makes for, well, a wild night. It’s a well-staged, personable work that’s sure to delight 90’s kids and even those, like me, who are a little older, and probably younger as well. Bring your stuffed animals, fuzzy slippers, and Trapper Keepers to the Greenfinch, and enjoy a fun show with an intelligent literary twist.
Young Liars is presenting Wild Nights at Greenfinch Theater & Dive until June 13th, 2026




