Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: a Sherlock Holmes Mystery
by Ken Ludwig
Directed by Nisi Sturgis
The New Jewish Theatre
November 20, 2025
Nick Freed, Bryce A. Miller, John Wilson, Alicia Revé Like
Photo by Jon Gitchoff
New Jewish Theatre
It may be based on an iconic mystery series and its characters, but there’s no mystery about the appeal of Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: a Sherlock Holmes Mystery, as staged at The New Jewish Theatre under the direction of Nisi Sturgis. With clever staging, a sharp script, brisk pacing, and an excellent, enthusiastic cast, this tale of intrigue and mystery on the moors of Victorian England has its audience howling with laughter. The appeal is enhanced by great production values, and some fun audience participation gags.
The story is framed in a similar way to the popular comedic staging of Patrick Barlow’s adaptation of John Buchan’s The 39 Steps, but based on the even more well-known stories of celebrated detective character Sherlock Holmes (Nick Freed) and his intrepid assistant, Dr. Watson (Bryce A. Miller). This one is based on the classic story The Hound of the Baskervilles, in which the two are enlisted to help on case involving a murder on the moors bordering a country estate, as the proprietor has been killed in a manner that mirrors an old legend in the Baskerville family, involving a giant, ferocious dog. Watson narrates the story, and takes the principal role, although Holmes still figures prominently, and three performers billed as Actor One (Sean C. Seifert), Actor Two (John Wilson), and Actress One (Alicia Revé Like) each play a variety of roles as the story takes the crime-solving duo from the streets of London to the Devonshire countryside on a caper that involves old legends, romance, sinister plots, murder, and all kinds of intrigue.
Like The 39 Steps, this story has been framed as a comedy, with much of the humor coming from the multi-casting elements and quick pacing, along with a clever script that covers all the familiar beats of a Holmes story but streamlines it to emphasize comic elements and provide many elements to showcase the versatility of the performers. It’s a fun show, and I’ve seen an excellent production in St. Louis before, a few years ago. At NJT, what stands out this time is the audience participation element, as well as several self-referential and “breaking the Fourth Wall” moments that add much hilarity to the proceedings. The cast members are kept on their toes by the pacing, and they handle the workout with much energy and quick thinking, resulting in a hilarious evening of suspense and riotous laughter, with a haunting gothic-styled backdrop of dramatic music and excellent production values.
The creepy, haunting, suspenseful tone of the proceedings are greatly enhanced by means of a marvelously versatile and deceptively simple set by Reiko Huffman that consists of quick-change set pieces and various movable elements on wheels, all painted and styled in suitable Victorian fashion. And speaking of fashion, Michele Friedman Siler’s costumes do a great job of outfitting the characters, working well with fast character changes, and maintaining the 19th Century mood and style. There’s also strong work from lighting designer Katherine Stepanek, keeping the tone dark and haunting while making everything clearly visible to the audience and in keeping with the heightened comic tone. There’s also a memorable soundtrack and music designed and composed by Victoria Deiorio, recreated with flair for this production by Ethan Foss.
The cast that has been assembled here is nothing short of fantastic, led by Miller in a charming turn as the determined and often bewildered Watson, who is essentially the heart of this story. Freed is also effective and thoroughly credible as the mysterious but almost infuriatingly competent Holmes, and this duo’s interactions form much the humor here, although the three support players carry much of that weight as well. Miller also has easy rapport with Wilson’s most prominent character, the amiable Texan heir to the estate, Sir Henry Baskerville, who also has excellent moments with Like as the conflicted Beryl, with whom Sir Henry becomes smitten. Wilson also excels in his other roles, such as the grumpy Detective Lestrade, and Siefert and Like each play a variety of characters with enthusiasm and distinction, with Siefert as the mysterious Jack Stapleton and supportive Dr. Mortimer, and Like memorable as the sympathetic Beryl and persistent young Cartwright, who helps Holmes on the case in London. There’s so much energy in this show, and the rapport the performers have with one another and with the audience contributes to the overall enjoyment here, with a few wardrobe mishaps being covered well and adding to the humor to the point in which it’s not entirely clear if they really were mishaps or if they were planned. The building suspense and overall gothic tone is well-maintained by the cast as well, providing much in entertainment value.
“Entertaining” is a great word for the overall experience here. That, and “fun”, for the audience and apparently for the cast as well. I also appreciate the staging with the audience divided and the performance area in the middle, which is a format this company has used before to excellent effect. For Sherlock Holmes fans, I think this show would be especially appealing, although there’s enough broad appeal for anyone. It’s a good way for NJT to end their season with a flourish, and a roar of laughter from their audience.
Sean C. Seifert, Alicia Revé Like
Photo by Jon Gitchoff
New Jewish Theatre
The New Jewish Theatre is presenting Ken Ludwig’s Baskerville: a Sherlock Holmes Mystery at the J’s Wool Studio Theatre until December 7, 2025
