Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
Book by Douglas McGrath
Words and Music by Gerry Goffin & Carole King, Barry Mann & Cynthia Weil
Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge
Choreographed by Patricia Wilcox
The Muny
June 13, 2023

Steven Good, Sara Sheperd, Noah Weisberg, Jarrod Spector, Jackie Burns
Photo by Phillip Hamer
The Muny
The Muny’s 105th season has begun in Forest Park, and it’s off to a great start. Beautiful: The Carole King Musical is making a strong impression way beyond simple nostalgia. With a great cast, excellent production values, and thoughtful staging, it’s a tribute not just to a great singer-songwriter, but to several musical eras and the overall evolution of the pop music scene.
As the title says, this show is about Carole King, the legendary singer-songwriter known for her collaborations with first husband Gerry Goffin, as well as her celebrated solo career. Even though King’s career went beyond the early 1970s, this show focuses mostly on her formative years, beginning and ending in 1971 and framed as a reflection/flashback showing how King got to this point, a concert at Carnegie Hall supporting her famous album Tapestry. From that legendary stage, we go back to Brooklyn in the late 1950s, where teenage Carole (Sara Sheperd) is a college student and aspiring songwriter, even though her mother, Genie (Sharon Hunter) wants her to be a teacher. Carole is persistent, and heads to Times Square and the office of record producer Don Kirschner (Noah Weisberg), who buys her first song. Soon, she finds herself struggling to write good lyrics, and meets Gerry Goffin (Steven Good), who becomes her writing partner and, eventually, her husband. The story then follows their success as songwriters and the development of the music industry and the trends in music, as well as Carole and Gerry’s friendship and professional rivalry with fellow songwriting couple Cynthia Weil (Jackie Burns) and Barry Mann (Jarrod Spector). The story also covers Carole’s personal struggles with her increasingly difficult marriage, as well as her development as an artist in her own right.
I’ve seen this show before, when the national tour based on the Broadway production came to the Fox Theatre. That was an excellent production, and I was sort of expecting a similar staging at the Muny, but this isn’t a replica of that staging. As directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge and featuring a dynamic set by Ryan Douglass, this show evokes the look, sound, and overall vibe of the era with an always moving but also reflective energy. The costumes by Tracy Christensen fit the characters well and illustrate the changing times with style. There’s also dazzling lighting by Rob Denton and excellent video design by Kylee Loera. The Muny Orchestra, led by music director Charlie Alterman, does an excellent job with the familiar score of pop hits by King and a variety of others including the Shirelles, the Righteous Brothers, The Drifters, and more.
As for the cast, Sheperd makes an ideal Carole King, with her strong vocals and relatable stage presence. Sheperd manages to do justice to King’s hit songs as well as portraying the artist as she grows and matures. Sheperd works especially well with Good, who’s impressive as the increasingly troubled Goffin; as well as Burns and Spector, who display strong chemistry and great voices as Weil and Mann. There’s also excellent work from Weisberg as the ambitious, encouraging Kirschner, and Hunter as King’s supportive mother. The ensemble, playing a variety of roles from famous recording artists, to fans, to friends, is also memorable, contributing to the story with energy and strong vocals.
It was a packed audience on press night, full of appreciative fans who clapped along to the music, danced in their seats, and contributed to the enthusiastic Muny atmosphere on a truly beautiful evening in Forest Park. This production of Beautiful certainly lives up to its title. It’s a thoughtfully staged, ideally cast show that serves as a magnificent beginning to a promising Muny season.
The Muny is presenting Beautiful: The Carole King Musical in Forest Park until June 18, 2023