Anastasia the Musical
Book by Terrence McNally
Music and Lyrics by Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens
From the Play by Marcelle Maurette as Adapted by Guy Bolton
Directed by Brittanie Gunn
Choreographed by Michelle Sauer
Tesseract Theatre Company
November 14, 2024

Sarah Wilkinson, Aaron Fischer
Photo by FF
Tesseract Theatre Company
Tesseract Theatre Company has become especially ambitious lately, staging more musicals, and generally “bigger” shows than ever before. Their latest production, Anastasia the Musical, continues this trend, but also manages to “shrink” the show to an almost intimate production that focuses largely on character and singing, but also features production choices that make the most of the small-ish theatre space at the Marcelle and their more limited resources appear more as an asset than a limitation. With smart direction, energetic choreography, a consistent artistic vision, and a great cast, this is more proof that Tesseract is living up to its ambitions.
The show is essentially based on the animated film from 1997, but also from the previous non-musical stage version by Marcelle Maurette, which formed the basis for the 1956 film starring Ingrid Bergman. Much of the film score is here, including perhaps its most well-known song, “Journey to the Past”, but thankfully the story has been modified to bring it a little more “down to Earth” and removing the zombie-like Rasputin as the villain and having a much less cartoonish antagonist in Gleb (Donald Kidd), a Bolshevik official who has reasons of his own to oppose the scheme of the enterprising Dmitry (Aaron Fischer) and Vlad (Kent Coffel) to pass off young amnesiac street sweeper Anya (Sarah Wilkinson) as the Grand Duchess Anastasia, who is rumored to have survived the assassination of the rest of her family. For those three, however, things get complicated as what starts out as a scam develops into burgeoning feelings between Anya and Dmitry, and Anya starts recovering memories that suggest maybe she really is the long-lost Grand Duchess. Also, Anastasia’s grandmother, the Dowager Empress (Margery A. Handy) waits in Paris and has grown weary of the long line of imposters who have written her letters claiming to be her granddaughter. Vlad, who used to be a member of the Romanovs’ court, has a former romantic connection with the Dowager’s lady-in-waiting, the Countess Lily (Kimmie Kidd), and he and Dmitry hope they can use her influence to get Anya seen by the Dowager. Meanwhile, Gleb is still on their trail, and Anya isn’t sure what’s going to happen when and if she does regain her memories.
As an animated film, and as a show produced on Broadway, this was a grand, sweeping, relatively large cast story. Here, on stage at the Marcelle, it’s a thoughtfully staged smaller cast show that still manages to keep a sense of scale despite space and cast-size limitations. Kudos to director Brittanie Gunn for the character-focused staging, choreographer Michelle Sauer for energetic and memorable dancing and movement, and the band led by music director Zach Newman for emphasizing the lushness of the score, even though there are moments when the music can overpower the singers, although that seems to be a regular issue with this venue. There’s also well-realized set design by Todd Schaefer that evokes early 20th Century Russia and Paris in an elegant way, augmented by Kevin Bowman’s atmospheric lighting and Sarah Gene Dowling’s detailed, period-specific costumes.
The cast is excellent, and the singing is exceptional from everyone involved. In addition to the remarkable performance of Wilkinson as a thoroughly believable Anya, there’s also a strong turn from Fischer as the initially scheming but gradually won over Dmitry. The scenes between these two are a highlight, as are all of the moments with Coffel as the charmingly enterprising Vlad and Kimmie Kidd as the stylish Lily. Donald Kidd is effective and in strong voice as the conflicted Gleb, and Handy is also strong as the grieving Dowager Countess. The entire ensemble is impressive, with the rest of the players filling a variety of roles as needed. Tiélere Cheatem, Scott Degitz-Fries, Ella Drake, Danielle Feinstein, Julia Gilbert Gaglio, Lindsey Grojean, Jaelyn Hawkins, Stephanie Merritt, Jacob Schmidt, and Kelvin Urday all deserve credit for their versatile, energetic performances and excellent singing, with some memorable ensemble numbers including “Stay, I Pray You”–featuring Cheatem in a poignant solo–as well as the lively “Paris Holds the Key” and more. The music here is a special highlight of this production, with lush harmonies and strong, clear vocals.
Anastasia the Musical is another excellent musical offering from Tesseract Theatre Company. You may know the animated film, but this show takes that story and brings it a degree of depth and poignancy that I haven’t seen in previous versions of this story. It’s a story of determination, discovery, and hope, well-staged by this excellent cast and creative team.
The Tesseract Theatre Company is presenting Anastasia the Musical at the Marcelle Theatre until November 24, 2024






