Snoop's Theatre Thoughts

The Inheritance Part One and Part Two
by Matthew Lopez
Inspired by the Novel Howards End by E.M. Forster
Directed by Stephen Peirick
Tesseract Theatre Company
April 26 and May 2, 2024

Gabriel Paul, Chris Kernan
Photo by Florence Flick
Tesseract Theatre Company

I can’t think of a better word than “epic” to describe Tesseract Theatre Company’s latest production, the two-part, seven hour drama The Inheritance, which was performed over two weekends at the Marcelle Theatre. A somewhat loose adaptation and updating of an E.M. Forster classic, this story follows a group of gay men in New York City and explores generational differences, relationships, and legacies in a highly personal manner. At Tesseract, as directed by Stephen Peirick, this marathon theatrical experience boasts a first-rate cast and fascinating staging that held the audience’s attention through two full-length plays worth of gripping drama. 

Even though the program says this play was “inspired by” Forsters’ Howards End, and playwright Matthew Lopez certainly adapts that story to fit his own storytelling purpose, it follows the basic plot structure of its source novel surprisingly closely, especially in the thread that follows the earnest activist Eric Glass (Chris Kernan) and wealthy businessman Henry Wilcox (Jonathan Hey). As the story begins, Eric and his long-term boyfriend, aspiring writer Toby Darling (Gabriel Paul) are living in New York City and frequently hosting their various friends–all gay men of varying professions and personal aspirations. They soon become acquainted with Adam (Tyson Cole) who gets his shopping bag mixed up with Toby’s. The ambitious but secretive and hedonistic Toby soon becomes somewhat obsessed with Adam, who becomes the star of Toby’s new play. Eric, meanwhile, forms a friendship with his neighbor Walter (Alex C. Moore), an older, man who tells Eric stories and memories of his house in upstate New York that he bought with his partner Henry to be a retreat from the city, but eventually became a place for Walter to take care of his many friends who were dying as a result of the AIDS epidemic, while also becoming a point of contention between him and Henry. If you’ve read Howards’ End, or seen any of the filmed versions of the story, you probably know where this is going. 

Although this story is told in two parts that are both three act, full-length plays, it’s essentially one very long play that has to be broken up for time. It’s essentially a mini-series onstage, and Part Two continues the story, focusing more on Eric’s relationship with Henry as well as the important role that Walter’s house plays in the story. It also follows Toby’s story as he plunges into indulgence and excess, eventually reckoning with the past he’s tried to hide. We also get to know Leo (also Cole), who showed up in part one as a young man Toby pays for a sexual encounter, but later returns and becomes a major focus of the story. We also get to meet Margaret (Margery Handy), the caretaker of Walter’s house, who has a poignant story of her own. 

There’s a lot of story here, and a lot of focus on the differences in the lives of gay men of different generations and cultural backgrounds. E.M. Forster himself (also Moore) also appears as an influence on the story, but the characters have some challenges for him in terms of how he lived his life in a time when gay men couldn’t be as open about their lives as they can now. Many other issues are raised in dialogue, and there are some moments where characters seem to be reciting issues more than acting them out, but for the most part, this is an effecting, powerful piece of theatre that challenges perspectives, educates about important history, and expounds on the importance of connection, compassion, and legacy, especially among gay men. 

The cast is excellent, led by Kernan in a compelling, engaging turn as the idealistic but self-doubting Eric, Cole in a dual role as the rising star actor Adam and the struggling, intellectually curious Leo. Paul, in the difficult role of the self-destructive writer Toby, is also fantastic, making a character who is hard to like fascinating and sympathetic. There is also a strong turn from Moore in the dual role of E.M. Forster (who goes by “Morgan”) and Walter, making both characters compelling and memorable. He also shines as the somewhat prickly Henry, and Handy makes the most of her fairly short stage time with some terrific work as Margaret. The rest of the cast is also excellent, with Stephen Henley, Donald Kidd, Kevin O’Brien, Jacob Schmidt, Sean Seifert, Nic Tayborn, and  Kelvin Urday all turning in strong performances in a variety of roles and contributing to the overall ensemble chemistry in a convincing way.

The production design works well in maintaining the overall tone of the story, with a simple but effective set by director Peirick that adapts well to the various changes of time, place, and situation. Tony Anselmo’s lighting is especially impressive in conveying the various shifting moods of the story. There’s also excellent work from sound designer Jacob Baxley and dialect coach Mark Kelley.

This has been an especially ambitious undertaking by Tesseract, which has become more bold as of late, with their successful venture into musicals, as well as bigger productions in general. The Inheritance is a riveting, intelligent, emotional theatrical experience, with a strong sense of structure as well as an inventive use of its source material. Although it doesn’t always follow the plot of Howards End exactly, I found it especially helpful to know that story while watching this one. This was a marathon of a play, and a remarkable success for Tesseract Theatre Company.

Cast of The Inheritance ( in Part 2)
Photo by Florence Flick
Tesseract Theatre Company